i don't know if that's a no brainer, but i currently have a nokia 5300 and i've been very happy with it, very user friendly and all that and i find downloading music is really easy, and i'm thinking if im going to upgrade, might as well to nokia 5610, which is a logical leap from 5300.

However, the samsung i450 has caught my eye, i think it looks really cool and i've been looking it up on the net, and it looks pretty good, should be pretty good and the prices are almost the same. But which is better, really? That's the part im trying to figure out

it's a cool and stylish and smartphone but the weakness is the D-pad is too sensitive and transfering data using bluetooth takes very long time even is under 100 kb and the UI is not really friendsly (i think so)



this phone is cool too,stylish and u know the UI is very friendly and its music edition so if u are music lover u can consider this phone
my suggsetion is go for 5610 if u are music lover and samsung i450 if u are smartphone lobver

hmm... will go for the 5610, thanks!

I'll recommend you Nokia 5610

go with nokia 5610

In i450 u will get S60 OS for many third party apps and it has 3D surround sound with bang and olufsen technolozy which is even better than Walkman.if we compare it to 5610 i wud suggest u 2 go wid i450 Bcoz nokia Sucks BIG TIME

5610 is good phone u can go for it